The conventional order is taxable accounts first, tax-deferred accounts second, Roth accounts last. The better version is a blend: each year, take enough from tax-deferred money to fill the low tax brackets, cover the rest of your spending from the taxable account, and leave the Roth to grow for last. The reason is required minimum distributions, which eventually force tax-deferred money out on the government's schedule; a smaller balance by then means smaller forced withdrawals and a lower lifetime tax bill.
The three tax buckets and how each withdrawal is taxed
Retirement money sits in three kinds of accounts, and the difference is when the IRS collects. A taxable brokerage account holds money that was taxed before it went in, so the tax on the way out is only on the growth: interest and non-qualified dividends count as ordinary income every year, the profit on a holding sold after more than a year is a long-term capital gain taxed at its own lower rates, and the part of a sale that is your original cost is not taxed at all. A tax-deferred account (a traditional 401(k), a traditional IRA, a 403(b)) holds money that was never taxed: every dollar withdrawn is ordinary income, and the account comes with a required minimum distribution once you reach the age the law sets. A Roth account holds money that was taxed going in, so qualified withdrawals, growth included, are tax-free, and a Roth IRA never forces its owner to withdraw.
| Bucket | Examples | How withdrawals are taxed | When withdrawals are forced |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taxable | Brokerage account, savings | Only the gain on a sale (long-term rates after a year); interest and non-qualified dividends taxed yearly | Never |
| Tax-deferred | Traditional 401(k), traditional IRA, 403(b) | Every dollar is ordinary income | RMDs from an age set by law (early seventies); heirs usually have ten years |
| Roth | Roth IRA, Roth 401(k) | Tax-free once the account is five years old and you are 59½ | Never for the owner; heirs have ten years |
The bucket matters more than the amount. $100,000 from a Roth is $100,000 to spend; from a traditional IRA it is $100,000 of taxable income; from a brokerage account it is taxed only on the gain, perhaps $30,000 of it. Same withdrawal, three very different tax bills.
The conventional order: taxable first, tax-deferred second, Roth last
The textbook order spends the taxable account first, then the tax-deferred account, then the Roth. The logic is sound as far as it goes: the tax-advantaged accounts shelter growth from annual taxes, so spending the taxable money first keeps the sheltered dollars sheltered longest. Roth goes last because it is the most valuable shelter of the three: the growth is never taxed, and heirs inherit it tax-free as well. It is simple, and it is what most people do by default.
Its weakness is that it ignores the tax brackets. Spending taxable money first means years of paying almost nothing in tax while the traditional IRA keeps growing. Then Social Security and RMDs land together on a much larger balance. The low-bracket years were wasted, and the later years are taxed at higher rates than they needed to be.
The better version: fill the low brackets from tax-deferred money every year
The improvement is to treat each year's low brackets as a resource that expires on December 31. A retiree with no wages has a standard deduction and the lowest brackets available every year, used or not. So the blend: withdraw from the tax-deferred account up to the top of a low bracket (the retirement withdrawal calculator shows where that line sits for a given year and filing status), and cover the rest of the year's spending from the taxable account, where the tax is only on the gain. The Roth is left alone.
In the years when income is lowest of all (the gap between retiring and claiming Social Security, a year with large deductions, a year you spend less), the same low brackets can be filled with a partial Roth conversion instead: moving money from the traditional IRA to the Roth, paying ordinary income tax on it now at the low rate, and never paying tax on it again. Roth conversion explained covers the mechanics and the five-year clock, and the Roth conversion calculator prices a given conversion. Either way, tax-deferred money leaves the account at a low rate before the forced withdrawals arrive at a higher one. The Roth stays for the end: it compounds tax-free the longest, and it is the right source for a one-off expense (a roof, a medical year) that would otherwise push a year into a higher bracket.
Required minimum distributions: the constraint that forces the order later
RMDs are the reason the order matters at all. From an age set by law (your early seventies; Congress raised it twice in recent years, and irs.gov has the current figure), you must withdraw a minimum amount from every tax-deferred account each year: the prior December 31 balance divided by a life-expectancy factor from an IRS table. The factor shrinks every year, so the required share rises. The RMD calculator does the division, and RMD rules explained covers which accounts count and the penalty for missing one. The rule does not care whether you need the money. A $1.5 million IRA produces a required withdrawal in the tens of thousands in the first year, all ordinary income, stacked on top of Social Security, whether you spend it or not.
That is why draining tax-deferred money early, at low rates, pays off: every $100,000 that leaves before RMDs begin is $100,000 that will never be divided by a shrinking factor, and money converted to a Roth IRA escapes the schedule entirely.
Qualified charitable distributions: the lever for people who give
A qualified charitable distribution sends money directly from an IRA to a charity. It counts toward the year's RMD but never appears in your taxable income, which beats taking the money and deducting the gift, because most retirees take the standard deduction and get nothing from an itemized charitable deduction. The QCD has its own age rule (a little before RMD age) and an annual cap that the IRS indexes; both are on irs.gov. For someone who already gives $5,000 a year, routing the gift through the IRA removes that much ordinary income from the return every year: the charity gets the same dollars, and the RMD is satisfied untaxed.
How Social Security timing interacts with the withdrawal order
Social Security can be claimed from 62, and every month you wait, up to 70, raises the check for life. The Social Security claiming guide walks through the trade-off, and the Social Security calculator shows the amounts by claiming age. Delaying creates gap years with no benefit and no wages, the lowest-income years you will ever have and the ideal time to fill brackets from the IRA or convert to Roth. Claiming early fills those years with benefit income and leaves less room for cheap withdrawals.
There is a second interaction. How much of each Social Security check is taxable depends on a formula over your other income (ssa.gov publishes the thresholds), so an IRA dollar withdrawn in a benefit year can drag more of the benefit into taxable income, and its effective tax is higher than its bracket suggests. Shrinking the IRA before benefits start sidesteps a good part of that.
Worked example 1: Maya, 62, with $1.2 million across three buckets
Maya retires at 62 with $400,000 in a brokerage account (cost basis $250,000), $650,000 in a traditional IRA, and $150,000 in a Roth IRA. She spends $70,000 a year and will claim Social Security at 70. The figures are illustrative; tax effects are described by direction because the brackets change every year.
Conventional order. She sells $70,000 of brokerage holdings a year. Only the gain is taxed, around $26,000 of each $70,000 at her basis ratio, and at long-term rates that is a very small bill; for roughly six years she pays almost nothing. Meanwhile the untouched IRA grows: at a modest return it is near $850,000 at 70 and past $1 million when RMDs begin. Then Social Security and a required withdrawal in the high tens of thousands arrive together, every year, at ordinary rates.
Blended order. Each year she takes about $40,000 from the IRA, enough to use her standard deduction and the lowest bracket, and sells about $30,000 of brokerage holdings for the rest. The IRA withdrawal is taxed at the cheapest rates she will ever see, and the sale only on its $11,000 or so of gain. Over the eight years to 70 she moves about $320,000 out of the IRA at low cost; the IRA that reaches RMD age is roughly half the size, so the forced withdrawals are roughly half, and far less of her Social Security is dragged into taxable income. The capital gains tax calculator prices the brokerage sales; the retirement withdrawal calculator prices the IRA draw for a given year.
Worked example 2: Omar, 68, with most of his money tax-deferred
Omar is 68, has $900,000 in a traditional 401(k), $120,000 in a brokerage account and $60,000 in a Roth IRA, and already receives $30,000 a year in Social Security. He spends $60,000 a year, so he needs $30,000 from savings, and RMDs are a few years away.
The conventional order would have him spend the brokerage account for four years and then start on the 401(k) right as RMDs begin, on a balance grown toward $1 million. The blend: he takes the $30,000 he needs from the 401(k) every year, since that income plus his benefit still sits in the low brackets (illustrative), and keeps the brokerage account as a reserve. Before RMDs begin he also converts an extra $30,000 a year to his Roth IRA, paying the tax from the brokerage account so the whole $30,000 lands in the Roth. By the time RMDs start, roughly $240,000 has left the 401(k) at low rates and the first required withdrawal is several thousand dollars smaller, a gap that widens as the divisor shrinks. At the QCD age he rolls the 401(k) into an IRA (QCDs come only from IRAs) and routes his $6,000 of yearly gifts through it, off his return for good.
Sequence risk: which holding to sell in a down year
The order above is about taxes. A second rule sits on top: in a year when the market is down, sell what has not fallen. Sequence of returns risk is the damage done by selling stocks at depressed prices early in retirement, and the bucket order does nothing to prevent it. Most people hold a year or two of spending in cash or short-term bonds inside the bucket they are drawing from and spend that in a down year. Taxes decide which account; the market decides which holding.
The retire with confidence collection has the rest: RMD rules, Roth conversions, claiming Social Security, and sequence risk.
The order only works when you can see the three buckets at once. Stoia's net worth tracking keeps every brokerage, retirement and Roth balance side by side, updated through read-only connections, so the mix you are drawing from this year is a number on the screen rather than a guess, launching in 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Which retirement account should I withdraw from first?
The textbook order is the taxable brokerage account first, tax-deferred accounts such as a traditional 401(k) or IRA second, and Roth accounts last. Most retirees do better with a blend: take enough from the tax-deferred account each year to use up the low tax brackets, cover the rest from the taxable account, and leave the Roth untouched for last. The blend keeps the tax-deferred balance smaller by the time required minimum distributions begin.
Should I take money from my IRA before Social Security starts?
Often, yes. The years between retiring and claiming Social Security are usually the lowest-income years of your life, so IRA withdrawals and partial Roth conversions made then are taxed at the lowest rates you will see. Once benefits and required minimum distributions start, the same withdrawal is taxed at a higher rate and can pull more of the benefit into taxable income.
Do Roth IRAs have required minimum distributions?
No. A Roth IRA has no required minimum distributions for its original owner, which is why it is the account to draw last and the best one to leave to heirs. Roth 401(k) accounts follow the Roth IRA rule for the owner under current law. Heirs of either account usually have to empty it within ten years.
What is a qualified charitable distribution?
A qualified charitable distribution is a gift sent directly from an IRA to a charity. It counts toward the year's required minimum distribution but is never added to your taxable income, so it is more valuable than taking the money and deducting the gift, especially for the majority of retirees who take the standard deduction. It has its own age rule and an annual cap, both published on irs.gov.
Why not just spend the taxable account first?
Because it wastes the low brackets. Spending taxable money first means years of paying almost nothing in tax while the traditional IRA keeps growing, and then Social Security and required minimum distributions arrive together on a much larger balance. Filling the low brackets from the IRA each year spreads the tax over more years at lower rates.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Figures and third-party prices were checked at publication and may have changed. See our disclaimer.