Stoia
Guide · Crypto

How to Keep Crypto Safe: Exchange or Self-Custody, Two-Factor, Seed Phrases, and the Scams to Expect

By the Stoia team · October 21, 2026 · 7 min read

The safe setup for most people is an exchange account with app-based two-factor, a withdrawal allowlist and a withdrawal delay for the holdings you trade, and a hardware wallet, with its seed phrase on paper or metal in two places, for holdings worth more than a few thousand dollars. The rest is habit: never type a seed phrase into anything with a screen, send a small test transaction first, and treat anyone who contacts you first about your crypto as a scammer.

Exchange custody vs self-custody: who holds the keys

A cryptocurrency balance is controlled by whoever holds its private keys. On a crypto exchange the exchange holds the keys and you hold a login; that is custodial, like a bank balance without the deposit insurance (crypto holdings are not FDIC-insured, whatever the exchange's cash accounts may be). Self-custody means you hold the keys, in a hot wallet (software on a phone or computer, keys on a device that is online) or a hardware wallet (a small device that keeps the keys offline and signs a transaction only when you plug it in and press a button). The trade-off is which failure you prefer. With an exchange you can lose everything if it is hacked, becomes insolvent or freezes withdrawals, and you can recover a forgotten password. With self-custody nobody can freeze or lose your coins but you, and if the seed phrase is gone, nobody can help. A stablecoin faces the same choice; stablecoins explained covers the separate question of whether the peg holds.

Custody optionWho holds the keysWhat can go wrongWho it suits
Exchange accountThe exchangeHack, insolvency, frozen withdrawals, a stolen loginSmall holdings, active trading, anyone who would lose a seed phrase
Hot wallet (phone or desktop app)You, on an online deviceMalware, a fake app, a signed malicious approval, a lost phone with no backupSmall amounts you use on-chain
Hardware walletYou, on an offline deviceA lost seed phrase, a seed phrase typed into a website, a tampered secondhand deviceLong-term holdings over a few thousand dollars
Split: exchange for trading, hardware for holdingBothEach side's risks, limited to its shareMost people with meaningful holdings

App-based two-factor over SMS, and why: the SIM swap

Two-factor authentication adds a second proof at login. The text-message version is the weak one because of the SIM swap: an attacker with your name, phone number and a few details from a data breach convinces your carrier's support line, or bribes an employee, to move your number to their SIM. From that moment the codes go to them, and with a password reused from an old breach they are in. Leo lost a $25,000 exchange balance in forty minutes this way (illustrative, and typical). An authenticator app generates the code on your device, and a hardware security key must be physically present; either defeats the SIM swap. Three companions: a port-out PIN on your carrier account, a unique password from a password manager for the exchange, and an email address used for nothing else, with its own app-based two-factor.

Withdrawal allowlists and withdrawal delays

A withdrawal allowlist limits withdrawals to addresses you approved in advance, and adding a new address takes a lock of 24 to 48 hours with an email and a notification. A withdrawal delay holds any withdrawal from a new device, or after a password change, for a day. Together they turn a stolen login into a wait the attacker rarely survives: the email arrives, you cancel, you lock the account. They cost nothing, and most people never turn them on. Turn on every notification the exchange offers as well; the time between the alert and the loss is the only window you get.

The seed phrase: five rules

A seed phrase is the 12 or 24 words a wallet shows you once, at setup. It is not a password to the wallet; it is the wallet. Anyone who has the words has the coins, on any device, forever, and no password, two-factor or support ticket can undo that. Five rules. Never type it into a website, a form, a chat, or any app other than the wallet's own recovery screen. Never photograph it or keep it in cloud notes, email or a password manager; a seed in a screenshot is a seed in the cloud. Write it on paper or stamp it into metal, and keep two copies in two places (home and a safe deposit box, or two homes), each protected from fire and water. Never share it with anyone who says they are support: no wallet or exchange has a reason to ask, and every request is a theft in progress. And test the backup once, by restoring the wallet on a wiped device before moving real money in.

Token approvals, signing and test transactions

Connecting a wallet to a website means being asked to sign things. A signature can be harmless (proving you own the address) or it can be a token approval that lets a contract spend a given token from your wallet, sometimes without limit, forever. A malicious site dresses the approval up as a free claim or a reward; once signed, it drains the token whenever it likes. Read what you sign, prefer limited approvals, and revoke old ones periodically. Transactions cannot be reversed, so send $20 first to any new address, confirm it arrived, then send the rest. Copy addresses from the recipient or your own saved list, never from transaction history, where an attacker can plant a look-alike address sharing the first and last characters of one you use.

The five scams to expect

Five patterns account for most of the money lost, and all five begin with the other person reaching out. Fake support: a message, a forum reply or a search ad leads to a "support agent" who needs your seed phrase or a remote-control session to fix a problem you did not have. Giveaway doubling: a stream or post, often with a borrowed famous face, promises to send back twice whatever you send; Sam sent $2,000 and received nothing, the only possible outcome. Romance and "pig butchering" investment scams: weeks or months of friendship or romance, then a tip about a trading platform where your balance grows on screen; Nina put in $38,000 over four months, watched a dashboard say $71,000, and was asked for a $9,000 "tax" to withdraw, which is when the platform, the balance and the person vanished. Phishing look-alike sites: a domain one letter off the real one, reached through an ad or a link in a message, collecting your login and your two-factor code live. Fake wallet apps: an app store listing with the real wallet's name and logo that asks for your seed phrase to "import" your wallet.

The defense is the same in every case. Reach the exchange or wallet by a saved bookmark, never through a link or an ad. Never give a seed phrase to anyone. And treat any investment opportunity delivered by a new acquaintance as a scam until proven otherwise, which it never is.

What a hardware wallet costs relative to what it protects

A hardware wallet bought from the maker's own store costs roughly $60 to $200 (illustrative). Never buy one secondhand or from a marketplace reseller, because a tampered device arrives with its seed already known. Against $300 of holdings the device is a bad trade. Against $12,000 it is under 1% once, to remove the exchange's failure risk and most of the phishing risk; against $80,000 it is a rounding error. The usual threshold is when the holdings pass a few thousand dollars or a month's pay, whichever comes first. The device protects only what you move to it, so a split is common: the trading balance on the exchange, everything else on the device.

Tracking holdings read-only

Tracking what you own should never add a way to lose it. Exchanges issue API keys with separate permissions: read-only (see balances and history), trade, and withdraw. A portfolio tracker needs only the first, and a key with withdrawal permission sitting in a tracker is the whole balance one breach away. Self-custodied coins are tracked by their public address, which reveals nothing that lets anyone spend them. The point of tracking is proportion: how much crypto should you own sizes the position by its volatility against everything else, and the net worth calculator puts the number in context.

The records to keep for cost basis

Every sale, swap and purchase made with crypto is a taxable event in the United States, and crypto taxes basics explains why swapping one coin for another counts as a sale. The number that decides the tax is cost basis, what you paid including fees, and the exchange will not always have it, especially after transfers between exchanges and wallets. Keep, for every lot: the date, the coin, the amount, the price paid in dollars, the fee, and where it went. Export the full history from every exchange at least once a year; accounts close and histories disappear. Maya bought $5,000 of a coin and swapped it for another when it was worth $7,000: a $2,000 gain is due for that year even though no dollars came out. Crypto cost basis explained covers lot methods, and the crypto profit calculator shows the gain on a given lot.

The crypto basics collection has the rest: how much to own, taxes, cost basis, and stablecoins.

Stoia's net worth tracking keeps your accounts in one picture through read-only connections that can see balances and never move them, launching in 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safer to keep crypto on an exchange or in a wallet?

It depends on which failure you prefer. An exchange can be hacked, go insolvent or freeze withdrawals, but it can reset a forgotten password. A hardware wallet removes the exchange's risks, but if you lose the seed phrase nobody can recover the coins. Most people keep a trading balance on an exchange and move long-term holdings worth more than a few thousand dollars to a hardware wallet.

What is a seed phrase and where should I store it?

A seed phrase is the 12 or 24 words a wallet shows you at setup; anyone who has the words controls the coins on any device, forever. Write it on paper or stamp it into metal, keep two copies in two separate places protected from fire and water, and never type it into a website, photograph it, or store it in cloud notes or email. No legitimate support team ever asks for it.

Why is SMS two-factor authentication not safe for crypto?

Because of SIM swapping. An attacker convinces or bribes your carrier into moving your phone number to a SIM they control, and from then on every text-message code goes to them. Combined with a password from an old data breach, that is enough to drain an exchange account. An authenticator app or a hardware security key generates the code on something you physically hold, which a SIM swap cannot reach.

What is a pig butchering scam?

A long-con investment scam. Someone builds a friendship or romance over weeks or months, then introduces a trading platform where your balance appears to grow. The dashboard is fake; the deposits go straight to the scammer. When you try to withdraw, the platform demands a tax or fee first, then disappears. Losses are often tens of thousands of dollars because the victim keeps adding money while the numbers look good.

What records do I need to keep for crypto taxes?

For every lot: the date, the coin, the amount, the price paid in dollars, the fee, and where it moved. Every sale, swap and purchase made with crypto is a taxable event, and the gain is the sale value minus the cost basis, which exchanges often cannot supply after transfers between accounts. Export your full history from every exchange at least once a year.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Figures and third-party prices were checked at publication and may have changed. See our disclaimer.

Stoia opens on November 22,
hear it first

Join the list and we'll email you on launch day. We only write about the launch.

We'll only email you about the launch. Leave any time. Privacy