A fixed-rate mortgage locks one interest rate for the whole loan, so the principal and interest payment in month 360 is the same as in month one. An adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) locks a lower rate for an opening period, usually five, seven, or ten years, and then resets it on a schedule to a market index plus a fixed margin, with caps on how far each reset can move. The fixed loan costs more at the start and buys certainty. The ARM costs less at the start and hands you the risk of whatever rates do later. An ARM makes sense when you are confident you will sell or pay off the loan before the first reset and could still afford the capped worst-case payment if you are wrong.
What is the difference between a fixed-rate and an adjustable-rate mortgage?
Both are ordinary mortgages with the same amortization math: each payment covers the month's interest and pays down some principal, and the schedule is built to reach zero at the end of the loan term, usually 30 years. The only difference is who carries interest-rate risk. On a fixed loan the lender does: if rates rise, you keep your rate, and if they fall, you can refinance. On an ARM you do, after the opening period. Lenders charge for carrying that risk, which is why the fixed rate is normally higher than an ARM's starting rate on the same day.
Property taxes and homeowners insurance can still push the total monthly bill up on a fixed loan, through escrow. That is a separate issue from the rate, covered in escrow and property taxes. This guide is about the principal and interest part, the part the rate controls.
What do 5/1, 7/1, 5/6 and 10/6 mean?
Most ARMs sold today are hybrids: fixed for a stretch, then adjustable. The name tells you the schedule. The first number is how many years the starting rate is locked. The second number is how often the rate resets after that: a 1 means once a year, a 6 means every six months. So a 5/1 ARM is fixed for five years and then adjusts annually, a 7/1 is fixed for seven, and a 5/6 or 10/6 resets twice a year once its fixed period ends. The six-month versions became the common format when the mortgage market moved to a new benchmark index in the early 2020s, and the annual versions still exist. In every case the loan still runs the full 30 years; the first number is only the length of the rate guarantee.
How an ARM rate adjusts: index plus margin
At each reset, the new rate is built from two parts written into your loan note:
- The index is a published market rate the lender does not control. Most newer ARMs use the Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR), a measure of what it costs to borrow cash overnight with Treasury securities as collateral, usually as a 30-day average; some use a one-year Treasury yield. Indexes move with the federal funds rate and the wider bond market.
- The margin is a fixed number of percentage points the lender adds to the index. It is set at closing and never changes. Two lenders quoting the same start rate can have different margins, and the margin matters for every year after the fixed period.
Index plus margin is the fully indexed rate, usually rounded to the nearest eighth of a point. Here is the detail that surprises people: the start rate is often set below the fully indexed rate, so the rate can rise at the first reset even if the index has not moved at all. Worked: an ARM starts at 5.75%. At the first reset the index is 3.50% and the margin is 2.75%, so the fully indexed rate is 3.50% + 2.75% = 6.25%. The rate rises half a point on a day when nothing in the market changed. Many notes also set a floor, often the margin or the start rate, so the rate cannot fall below it however low the index goes.
Rate caps: how high an ARM can go
Caps limit each reset, and they are written as three numbers:
- Initial adjustment cap: the most the rate can move at the first reset.
- Periodic cap: the most it can move at each reset after that.
- Lifetime cap: the most it can ever rise above the start rate.
A 5/1 ARM with 2/2/5 caps starting at 5.75% can reach at most 7.75% in year six (5.75% + 2), 9.75% in year seven (7.75% + 2), and never more than 10.75% (5.75% + 5). Six-month ARMs usually carry a smaller periodic cap, often 1 point, because they reset twice as often, and some longer ARMs allow a first adjustment as large as the lifetime cap, written as 5/1/5 or 5/2/5. That last structure means the very first reset can take you all the way to the ceiling. Ask for the caps in writing: they are the only thing that turns "rates might go up" into a number you can test against your budget.
Payment shock: a $400,000 ARM worked through
Take a $400,000 loan over 30 years. The fixed quote is 6.5%. The 5/1 ARM quote is 5.75% with a 2.75% margin and 2/2/5 caps. All rates are illustrative. The fixed payment is $2,528; the ARM payment for the first five years is $2,334, which is $194 a month less. Over 60 months that is $194 × 60 = about $11,640 saved, and because the lower rate puts more of each payment toward principal, the ARM balance after five years is about $371,000 against $374,400 on the fixed loan. The ARM borrower is roughly $15,000 ahead on the day of the first reset. What happens next depends on the index:
| Year | 30-year fixed, 6.5% | 5/1 ARM, index flat at 3.5% | 5/1 ARM, worst case the caps allow |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 to 5 | $2,528 | $2,334 at 5.75% | $2,334 at 5.75% |
| 6 | $2,528 | $2,448 at 6.25% | $2,803 at 7.75% |
| 7 | $2,528 | $2,448 at 6.25% | $3,294 at 9.75% |
| 8 onward | $2,528 | $2,448 at 6.25% | $3,545 at 10.75% |
| Ahead or behind the fixed loan after year 7 (payments plus balance) | Baseline | About $17,300 ahead | About $1,150 behind, and falling further each year |
Each new payment is recalculated on the remaining balance over the remaining months, which is why the worst-case year-six payment is $2,803 rather than a simple rate swap on the original loan. From the ARM's start payment, that path is $468 more a month in year six and $1,211 more a month (52%) from year eight, and the $15,000 head start is gone by the end of year seven. The worst case needs the index to climb past 8%, which is rare but has happened in living memory; the flat case shows the more ordinary outcome, where the ARM stays cheaper than the fixed loan. Run your own rate and balance through the mortgage calculator at the start rate, the first cap, and the lifetime cap, and look at the third number before you look at the first.
Fixed-rate and ARM options compared
| Loan | Rate locked for | After that | Start rate vs. 30-year fixed | Usually fits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30-year fixed | 30 years | Nothing changes | The benchmark | Long or uncertain stays, budgets with little slack |
| 15-year fixed | 15 years | Nothing changes; loan is paid off | Usually lower, with a much higher payment | Strong cash flow, a goal of owning outright |
| 5/1 or 5/6 ARM | 5 years | Resets yearly or every six months | Usually the lowest of the hybrids | Buyers fairly sure they will move within about five years |
| 7/1 or 7/6 ARM | 7 years | Resets yearly or every six months | Between the 5-year ARM and the fixed rate | A five- to seven-year horizon |
| 10/1 or 10/6 ARM | 10 years | Resets yearly or every six months | Closest to the fixed rate, sometimes equal | Buyers who want a long head start with an exit date |
The gap between ARM and fixed rates is not constant. When short-term rates sit close to or above long-term rates (a flat or inverted yield curve), ARMs can be barely cheaper than a fixed loan, and a small discount is poor pay for taking on rate risk. When the gap is wide, the head start is large enough to matter. Compare the quotes on the same day from the same lender, and compare the APR as well as the rate, since an ARM's APR assumes the index stays where it is today, so it is a rough guide rather than a forecast.
When an adjustable-rate mortgage can make sense
The ARM case is a timeline case. It works when the loan is likely to end before the fixed period does:
- A known move. A job with a planned relocation, a starter home you expect to outgrow, a military or medical training posting with an end date.
- A planned payoff. A large bonus schedule, an expected inheritance, or the sale of another property that will retire most of the balance inside the fixed window.
- A large loan. On a jumbo loan, the dollar value of a given rate gap is bigger, and ARM pricing is sometimes more competitive.
- A budget that survives the cap. If the lifetime-cap payment would be uncomfortable but payable, the risk is a cost, not a catastrophe.
Worked: a buyer expects to relocate in about six years and takes a 7/1 ARM at an illustrative 6.0% instead of a 6.5% fixed on the same $400,000. The payment is $2,398 against $2,528, so $130 a month lower. Selling at month 72, before any reset, the buyer has saved $130 a month for 72 months, about $9,365, in payments and owes about $2,700 less at the sale, roughly $12,000 better off. If the move falls through and the first reset lands at the 5-point first cap some 7-year ARMs carry, the year-eight payment could be about $3,575, so that number is the one to test before signing.
When a fixed rate is the better choice
- You plan to stay. A home you expect to keep past the fixed period turns the ARM's discount into a loan from your future self.
- The budget is already full. If your debt-to-income ratio is near the limit at the start payment, a capped increase you cannot absorb means selling or refinancing on someone else's schedule.
- The plan depends on refinancing. A refinance needs income, credit, equity, and a market rate you like, all on the same day. Any one of them can be missing when the reset arrives.
- The discount is small. A quarter point of savings for five years rarely pays for decades of uncertainty.
If the goal is a lower payment without rate risk, there are fixed-rate ways to buy one. Paying mortgage points lowers a fixed rate permanently, and a temporary buydown lowers it for the first year or two; the mortgage points guide works through the break-even. And a fixed loan taken at a high rate can be refinanced later if rates fall, which is the one-way option the ARM gives up; the when to refinance guide and the refinance calculator show when that pays.
What lenders check differently on an ARM
Lenders know the start payment is not the real test. On ARMs whose fixed period is five years or shorter, they commonly qualify you at a rate above the start rate, so the lower payment does not always stretch your approval as far as you might expect. The pre-approval guide covers what a lender reviews, and how much house can I afford covers the budget test, which for an ARM should be run at the lifetime-cap payment rather than the teaser one. The mortgage affordability calculator shows the price range a given payment supports.
Questions to ask before you sign an ARM
- Which index does the loan use, and where is it published?
- What is the margin, and is there a floor?
- What are the initial, periodic, and lifetime caps, and what is the highest payment the loan can ever reach?
- How often does it reset after the fixed period?
- Is there a prepayment penalty, or an option to convert to a fixed rate, and what does conversion cost?
- Can the balance ever grow? Loans that allow negative amortization have largely left mainstream lending; if one is offered, walk away.
Lenders must give ARM applicants the federal consumer handbook on adjustable-rate mortgages, and the Loan Estimate for an ARM includes a table showing the index, margin, caps, and the highest rate the loan can reach. Both are explained at consumerfinance.gov. Before the first adjusted payment, the servicer must send a notice with the new rate and payment, which is your cue to compare refinance quotes. The amortization calculator shows how much of each payment goes to interest at each rate, and FHA vs. conventional covers the loan-type choice that sits beside this one. The rest of the path to closing is in the buy your first home collection.
Fixed or adjustable, the loan balance is the number that decides your options later, from refinancing to selling. Stoia keeps the mortgage next to the home value you enter in one net worth picture, so the equity behind any future decision is a number you can see rather than estimate.
Frequently asked questions
Is an adjustable-rate mortgage a good idea?
It can be when two things are true: you expect to sell, move, or pay off the loan before the fixed period ends, and you could afford the payment at the lifetime cap if that plan falls through. It is a poor fit for a home you plan to keep for decades, for a budget with no room for a higher payment, or for a borrower counting on a future refinance that depends on rates falling.
What happens when an ARM adjusts?
At each adjustment date the lender takes the current value of the index named in your note, adds the margin, which never changes, rounds the result as the note specifies, and limits it by the caps. That becomes your new rate until the next adjustment, and the payment is recalculated to pay off the remaining balance over the remaining term. Your servicer must send a notice with the new rate and payment before the first adjusted payment is due.
What is the difference between a 5/1 ARM and a 5/6 ARM?
Both keep the starting rate for five years. After that, a 5/1 adjusts once a year and a 5/6 adjusts every six months. Most newer ARMs follow the six-month pattern and use the Secured Overnight Financing Rate as their index, and their caps are usually smaller per adjustment because adjustments come twice as often.
Can you refinance an ARM into a fixed-rate mortgage?
Yes, as long as you qualify at the time: enough income, a good enough credit score, and enough equity. Refinancing costs closing costs and gives you whatever fixed rate the market offers that year, which may be higher than the fixed rate you passed up. Treat a refinance as a backup option, not as the plan that makes the ARM affordable.
Can an ARM rate go down?
Yes. If the index falls, the rate can fall at the next adjustment, limited by the same per-adjustment cap that limits increases and usually by a floor written into the note, often the margin or the start rate. A falling rate lowers the payment, but most ARM borrowers only benefit if rates fall while they still hold the loan after the fixed period.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Figures and third-party prices were checked at publication and may have changed. See our disclaimer.